Category Archives: Old Made New

Zathura

Looking forward to Ratatouille, and having recently engaged in a debate with a friend and colleague about the shelf life of the Fantastic Four sequel, I got to thinking about legitimately compelling kids’ films, and particularly those of the non-animated persuasion. That led me to think back to Zathura, so I’ll repost a redacted version of a DVD review of the movie that initially ran elsewhere, concurrent with its original release.

Wall Street again, and
taking it seriously), it’s probably on the surface less foolhardy to try to
handicap children’s films. After all, animated smashes like the Toy Story and Shrek franchises are built for the long haul — or maybe just deftly
sold as such. Take away animated films, though — admittedly a hug chunk of
kids’ films these days — and then try picking the last youth-skewing movie you
think you might actually want to revisit with your own children, grandchildren
or nieces and nephews somewhere down the line
. Are the Agent Cody Banks flicks or, God forbid, disposable tripe like Martin Lawrence’s Rebound going to have any residual sway
with the adolescent audiences of tomorrow?

Hopefully not, but I’ll wager that Zathura, actor-turned-director Jon Favreau’s crisp, smart adaptation of Jumanji
and The Polar Express author Chris
Van Allsburg’s sci-fi adventure tale, will hold up admirably, and stake itself
a deserving place in the DVD collections of discriminating film fans looking
for both wholesomeness and quality
. Chiefly a tale of fraternal strife and
reconciliation, the movie centers around two bickering brothers — athletic
pre-teen Walter (Josh Hutcherson, above left) and his diminutive, 6-year-old sibling, Danny
(Jonah Bobo, above right). When their father (Tim Robbins) leaves the boys alone in the care
of their inattentive teenage sister Lisa (Kristen Stewart), Walter and Danny
immediately start squabbling. A bored Danny soon finds an old, dusty, metallic
board game, and… presto chango!, the
entire house is magically transported into an outer space world rife with
meteor showers, malfunctioning robots, ice storms and carnivorous, lizard-like
creatures. The only way back “home” is for the family to work together and,
with the assistance of a wayward astronaut (Dax Shepard), complete the game.

Beautifully fleshed out in non-pandering fashion by
screenwriters David Koepp and John Kamps, Zathura
mines a deep reservoir of genuine feeling
often missing in adolescent entertainment, and combines this with enough spry
sensory pleasures to produce a winning piece of entertainment that, truly, the
whole family can enjoy. While Lisa is egregiously underwritten, other
characterizations are crisp, and conflict between the brothers exists in
perfectly measured fashion — not too heavy so as to be a drag, not too
contrived so as to come off as emotionally irrelevant
. All the films that push
off needlessly surly adolescents or histrionics in lieu of genuine pubescent
discord could stand to learn a thing or three from the smart, modulated set-up
of Zathura and the emotional
authenticity that subsequently flows naturally.

DVD special features on the movie’s single-disc, 1.85:1 anamorphic
widescreen release include an audio commentary track with Favreau and
co-producer Peter Billingsley
, a look at the making of the accompanying
videogame to the movie and a clutch of featurettes on the work of author Van
Allsburg, the cast, the visual effects and the like
. The best of these examines
the vanishing art of model miniatures, and includes interviews with Favreau,
miniatures supervisor Michael Joyce and others about the painstakingly detailed
construction of the six-foot replica of the house from the movie’s Glendale
location shoot. A hint for all you future model makers out there — the herb thyme
doubles nicely as bushes, since it doesn’t deteriorate or go bad. A- (Movie) B+
(Disc)

The Baxter

The Baxter’s
Elliot Sherman is the very embodiment of romantic compromise
. If George
Thorogood’s “Bad to the Bone” announces swaggering screen bad boys and
exotically flavored orchestral scores herald the arrival of cinema’s most
sensitive heartthrobs, Death Cab for Cutie’s “The Sound of Settling” would
serve as the putative theme song for Elliot, a dowdy but sincere accountant who
finds himself caught between well-heeled fiancée Caroline Swann (The 40-Year-Old Virgin’s Elizabeth
Banks) and Cecil Mills (Michelle Williams), a bookish temp who seems on the
surface a much better geek match given that both she and Elliot read the
dictionary as a book.

The Baxter marks
the feature directorial debut of Michael Showalter, who of course got his start
as part of the sprawling comedy collective The State — which achieved a cultish
following in the 1990s via an eponymous sketch show on MTV — and later went on
to co-script and produce the peerless summer camp send-up Wet Hot American Summer. Showalter’s leaping off point for The Baxter is the great screwball
romantic comedies of the 1930s and ’40s, films in which second male leads like
Ralph Bellamy and John Howard took it squarely on the chin when the Cary Grants
of the world swept in and relieved them of their women. (For a modern day
comparison, think of Bill Pullman’s jettisoned character from Nora Ephron’s Tom
Hanks-Meg Ryan romantic comedy Sleepless
in Seattle
.) The twist here is that The
Baxter
repositions the nice guy who never gets the girl (hence the stiff
but regal nickname) as its leading man, to drolly winning if extremely dry
effect
.

The film’s basic story arc finds Elliot (whom Showalter also
stars as) awkwardly attempting to assert himself and land his leading lady,
even if in his heart there’s some confusion as to whom that is. Though he’s not
a virgin, Elliot is a man-child whose unfailing politeness (“Like I always say,
compromise is the key to success…”) has metamorphosed into a sort of wussy,
serial acquiescence
. When Caroline’s dashing ex-boyfriend Bradley Lake (Justin Theroux) arrives on the scene, Elliot recognizes the familiar warning signs of
an impending dumping and reacts alternately with nice-guy petulance — think of
the most fastidious passive-aggressiveness possible — and wan resignation.

Showalter’s mannered comedy is as distinctive and guileless
as it is perhaps out-of-fashion, or at least decidedly non-mainstream. It stems
from situational awkwardness and absurdity, and is always perfectly balanced
between heaping helpings of earnestness and silliness. (Frequent collaborators
and Stella costars David Wain and
Michael Ian Black also pop up here, as Elliot’s emasculated
brother-in-law-in-waiting and a zonked-out neighbor, respectively.) It’s micro
comedy instead of macro comedy, in other words, and if broader humor and
joke-driven laughs are more your forte then you won’t want to waste your time
with The Baxter.

If wry, understated character comedy is up your alley,
though, you’ll likely dig this movie. For most of its running time, it really
works; things only bog down when Showalter starts relying too heavily on
narration and contrivance to advance scenes
. The former is funny when building
up the temperament and personality of Elliot, but less so after the parameters
of character roundelay have already been clearly established. A brief scene
with The Station Agent’s Peter
Dinklage as a (gay) wedding planner also falls flat.

The amusingly observant point of the film, though, is that
for all we allow others to dictate about our own self-perception and, in many
cases, worth, we are still the stars of our own stories
— our own leading men
and women. As Elliot rises, another must fall. It’s the circle of life, and we
all go through it at some point. (IFC Films, PG-13, 90 minutes) For an interview with Michael Showalter, click here.

The Big Red One: The Reconstruction

With Father’s Day looming just around the corner, I thought I’d do those potentially looking for a gift, as well as war movie fans in general, a solid, and re-post this review of the DVD release of The Big Red One, which bowed in a very special extended, restored edition in May of 2005. A slightly redacted version of my original review is as follows:

As a filmmaker, Samuel
Fuller developed a reputation for shock and coarseness
, but
nothing ever compared to the horrors that he lived through as a decorated
combat veteran of the First Infantry in World War II. In 1980, he made a movie loosely
based on his own experiences, but it was taken away and re-cut prior to its
theatrical release. Digitally restored and re-mastered, with 47 minutes
of never-before-seen footage
overseen by Time
critic and filmmaker Richard Schickel and Warner Bros. archivist Brian Jamieson
— who in 2005 were justly lauded with special citations from the Los Angeles Film
Critics Association
and National Board of Review for their work — The Big Red One: The Reconstruction rights that wrong, and stands
as a riveting renovation of one of the most underappreciated war dramas of our
time
.

Clocking
in at 162 minutes, The Big Red One is
introduced by a title card as “a fictional life based on factual death,” a
notation Schickel mentions was part of Fuller’s original screenplay as well as
the novelization of the film. It centers in undemonstrative fashion on the war
years of a gruff, unnamed sergeant (Lee Marvin, above right, painting in stark, effective
strokes of surly reticence
) who heads up a fresh-faced 12-man rifle squad
anchored by four men who just keep living through a litany of hellish
assignments, from the North African invasion of 1942 through Sicily in 1943,
D-Day and the liberation of a concentration camp. Those men are
Bronx writer Zab (Robert Carradine, Revenge of the Nerds’ Lewis Skolnick),
at-odds sharpshooter Griff (Mark Hamill), lanky Italian Vinci (Bobby Di Cicco)
and Johnson (Kelly Ward). Hamill and Carradine easily make the strongest
impressions, likely because their characters are the most obvious stand-ins for
Fuller himself, and his feelings of conflict on war.

The
bracing success of The Big Red One,
though, chiefly stems from the fact that it transposes the theorem that war
reduces everything to irrationality to even the setting of a “just war” like
World War II
, something a nation still reeling psychologically from the Vietnam
War had yet to come to grips with. In fact, the movie opens with a
black-and-white World War I sequence where a then-young Marvin unknowingly
slays a German soldier after an armistice has been called, and the
hollowed-out, ant-encrusted eyes of a wooden saint statue make clear that there
are no right and certain answers on the battlefield.

While
Hollywood battle choreography had not yet progressed to the level where actors
were put through intensive, grueling boot camps (and thus some of its action
still consists of the generic, run-around variety that looks silly in the wake
of expansive, real-time sieges like in Saving
Private Ryan
), The Big Red One
retains an impressive scope. Still, Fuller is more interested in pre-battle
moments — the tension, camaraderie and even surrealities of massive armed
conflict
. Sometimes these details are as darkly comedic or touching as they are
horrific (a solider attempting to wade ashore with a dry roll of toilet paper,
a wounded “wet nose” checking his privates after Marvin deceives him in an
effort to keep him from going into shock). Sometimes, though, the results are
less convincing: a pregnant woman on the battlefield and a gay German doctor
who plants one on a wounded Marvin in a brief sequence of detainment come
across as absurdist flourishes, and a parallel subplot involving a German
officer
akin to Marvin’s (some of their dialogue is even the same) doesn’t
fully connect.

Available
alongside director Ken Annakin’s new-to-DVD 1965 film Battle of the Bulge, itself a recreation of one of the most crucial
confrontations of World War II, The Big
Red One
is delivered on a great two-disc special edition, eclipsing by
miles the previous bare-bones, theatrical cut DVD incarnation. Reconstruction
producer Schickel provides an erudite and humble if waning commentary over the
feature on its first disc; the second disc houses alternate scenes,
before/after comparisons of the restoration work, a profile on Fuller, radio
spots and trailers and a photo gallery. There’s also a 1980 promo reel narrated
by Marvin, a 1946 short on the company produced by the War Department, and a
wonderful, 45-minute making-of documentary that features new interviews with
cast and crew, as well as archival footage of the director himself
, who died in
1997. For fans of brawny but intelligent war drama, The Big Red One delivers a heckuva punch. B+ (Movie) A (Disc)

Prime

Not that I’m a skeezy deejay and we’re opening up the
request line
here at Shared Darkness, but a reader e-asked me about the Uma Thurman flick Prime a couple days ago, and so I thought
I’d drop this slightly tweaked and redacted review, originally published to
coincide with the film’s DVD release, and penned for a site that still owes me
money
. To wit:

The Boondock Saints,
and it happened in 2000 with writer-director Ben Younger and Boiler Room, a sort of pre-Enron mash-up
of Wall Street
and The Firm for the Gen-X millennial
set in which a college dropout quickly rises the ladder at a suburban
securities and investment firm only to discover seedy goings-on. Unfortunately,
though, commercial grosses are often misread as qualitative tea leaves, and
when Boiler Room pulled in under $17
million at the box office despite the presence of a marquee young cast
including Ben Affleck in a supporting role, Younger went from Next Big Thing to
Just Another Forgotten Thing.

2005’s romantic comedy Prime
represents his return, and it’s in some small ways triumphant while in most other
ways right in lockstep with his debut — interesting and awkward, and more packed
with promise than fulfillment
. Despite the presence of a post-Kill Bill Uma Thurman and exalted
national treasure Meryl Streep, Prime
did hardly better in its theatrical release ($22 million domestically), the
result of a somewhat lackluster promotional campaign that couldn’t convincingly
sell the movie’s offbeat sense of humor, and/or convince audiences to come see
a film in which the male romantic lead was a virtual unknown.

The story centers around career-driven 37-year-old Rafi
Gardet (Thurman), who finds herself on the relationship rebound with 23-year-old
aspirant painter David (Bryan Greenburg, of the short-lived HBO series Unscripted),
the doted-upon son of Gardet’s very Jewish psychoanalyst, Lisa Metzger (Streep).
The more Rafi tells Lisa about her new young fling, the more Lisa catches on to
his true identity, and so she tries to subtly nudge both parties away from
continuing the relationship
. It’s a great concept, but a lot of the trite relationship
stuff rings relatively false, and proxy Greenburg can’t quite pull the weight
of his part. Still, upon further consideration, the movie plays better on the
small screen, where one can more fully give into the joys of Streep’s
pitch-perfect performance.

Younger has an idiosyncratic taste and voice, as evidenced
by a subplot in which David’s friend Morris (Jon Abrahams) seeks revenge on a
woman who spurns him by thrusting banana crème pies in her face. In some ways
both of his films have had palettes too large for conventional genre pieces;
you can tell he takes great delight in writing tangential bits, and for
supporting characters, and when required to push forward the chief narrative boulder he
falls back on clichés that are beneath him
. While neither of his studio films
have completely wowed me in aggregate, Younger seems like he would be better
suited toward more intimate, indie-scaled productions, like those of Whit Stillman, Noah
Baumbach and Nicole Holofcener.

DVD extras on Prime‘s single-disc release include nine minutes
of cast and crew interviews
in which Streep praises Younger as having “the
confidence of an old soul,” and producer Jennifer Todd talks about her initial
attraction to the material. Eight minutes of deleted scenes feature all kinds
of interstitial bits, odds and ends, and showcase in unique fashion the
challenges of feigning a loud party scene with no music. Also included are four
minutes of outtakes
, though these are frequently less outrageous bloopers than
halting, alternative versions of scenes, with a few laughs thrown in for good
measure. C+ (Movie) C+ (Disc)

Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room

I had a passing conversation recently with someone who’d flown through and spent an extra day in Houston, and was struck by the still-massive economic footprint of the Enron washout, several years down the line. I recommended Alex Gibney’s moving and beautifully depressing documentary, Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, and so I thought I’d post a review of the film, tweaked slightly from its original publication concurrent with the movie’s theatrical release. To wit:

The numbers hit you first, though not with the direct club
force of a riot baton that you might expect. Enron, the ascendancy: The seventh
largest corporation in the United States.
From $10 billion to $65 billion in business in under 10 years. Enron, the
aftermath: 24 days to complete bankruptcy. More than 20,000 shell-shocked
employees left without jobs, many given 30 minutes to clear out of the
company’s Downtown Houston office building. $1.2 billion in personal savings
and $2 billion in pensions wiped out, a financial tsunami
. Oh, and the other
numbers? A handful of executives waltzing away with hundreds of millions of
cashed-out stock options while their crew all went down with the proverbial
ship. There, it all starts to come together.

Written and directed by Gibney and an essential hit at the 2005 Sundance Film Festival, Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room is essential viewing for every adult trying to make sense of the insanity
and inanity of corporate culture
, and sure to be a continued zeitgeist talking
point for years, beyond the scope of punishments meted out to former (and now deceased) CEO Kenneth Lay and COO Jeff Skilling. Based on Fortune reporters Bethany McLean and Peter Elkind’s book of the
same name, and featuring insider accounts and incendiary corporate audiotapes
and videotapes — the worst of which find Enron traders laughing and praying for
wildfire and earthquakes as they induce California’s artificial power shortages
of 2000-01 and reap windfall profits from the gouging — this is as emotionally
destructive a movie as you’re likely to see any given year, because it’s all true
. The
brilliant achievement, though, is that Gibney takes what could simply be
boisterous denunciation and turns it into a call to action, a screaming
cautionary tale of pride, arrogance, outsized greed, ambition and intolerance
all run amok over “the little guy.”

It’s all too easy — fish in a barrel, really — to demonize
the bad guys of Enron. They deserve it, make no mistake. Asleep-at-the-wheel
Lay’s ridiculous cloak of moral rectitude doesn’t stand up to the righteous anger
of those called to represent the thousands he instructed to keep their savings
invested in company stock while he and other executives engaged in a
behind-closed-doors fire sale. But to stop there is to miss the larger point:
that the Enron scandal is important because it takes the predatory nature of
big business and money-hungry capitalism to its logical extension — an
insidious, incremental creep into fraudulence
. The company did not exist in
some bubble, and it’s not an exception to the rule; it’s a jaw-dropping,
eye-opening of the way things too often work, as the collateral damage
destruction of accounting firm Arthur Andersen and tainting of a wide number of
savings and loans and financial lenders complicit in Enron’s schemes (and if
you have a credit card, chances are they’re one of your companies) amply
demonstrate.

Narrated by Peter Coyote, Gibney’s documentary traces the
rise and fall of the company with remarkable clarity, and it’s surprising how
heart-rending it is without dipping into cheap sentimentality
(the defrauded
pensioners are embodied only by one PGE utility line worker, who saw his life
savings of $350,000 shrink to $1,2000). Skilling comes across the purveyor of a
corporate culture that allowed for corruption and decay, but Chief Financial
Officer Andrew Fastow is the architect of its fiscal shell games. The film,
though, comes full circle, developing into a disquisition on the nature of evil
— is it amorality, willful negligence in the pursuit of personal gain, or
perhaps an overlapping combination of the two?

In the end, it’s the numbers that start to hit you again. Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room
will likely make you mad as hell. The question is whether or not you’re going
to take it anymore. (Magnolia, unrated, 109 minutes)

The Majestic

It’s the beginning of the month and I’m fleshing out the archive a bit, though in admittedly slow-hand fashion. Next on the docket: this review of The Majestic, originally published upon its theatrical release in 2001. Why now? Let’s say… because I just saw Jim Carrey and Jenny McCarthy having sex in the hot tub which my balcony overlooks. Does that work? Did that get your attention? OK, settle down. On to the review:

The elastic-faced Jim Carrey, who started his career on Fox’s sketch comedy show In Living Color and first sprung to cinematic prominence in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective by talking with his butt cheeks and sporting a pompadour that would shame both an “Uptown Girl”-era Billy Joel and a modern day Chris Isaak, has been on a slow and steady quest to get serious. His first two dramatic feature film leads, The Truman Show and Man on the Moon, brought mixed results. For the most part critically lauded, both as a whole and with respect to his performances, the films secured Carrey Golden Globe Best Actor wins from the Hollywood Foreign Press Association (though the latter was curiously in the comedic category, something Carrey himself poked fun at in his acceptance speech). Yet each film was met with degrees of indifference at the box office, as well as virtual Academy Award lock-outs. What, then, to make of these mixed signals?