State of Affleck: Please Don’t Play

Old news, but Ben Affleck has stepped in for Edward Norton in Universal’s State of Play. This after Russell Crowe took over for costar Brad Pitt, who bailed only a few weeks before production was set to commence. The movie — based on a six-hour British miniseries of the same name — centers on a House member whose speedy political rise is
threatened by an investigation into the death of his mistress. Crowe plays a politico-turned-journalist whose relationship with the lawmaker (Affleck) is
compromised when he oversees his newspaper’s investigation into the
murder, and subsequently develops a relationship with the pol’s estranged wife.

Can anyone honestly say this pairing makes them more excited and interested in seeing the movie than a Pitt-Norton pairing? After Gone Baby Gone, I’m much more interested in Affleck’s career as a director than I am in seeing him in front of the camera anymore, especially in something where he has to lock horns with a heavyweight like Crowe. Affleck’s on-screen appeal, as it were, was always rooted in a matinee idol’s identification and a nimble sense of cleverly apportioned timing, and maybe that’s why it makes sense to some to cast him as a smooth, glad-handing politician. When he tries to play cunning, though, (e.g., Boiler Room), it just doesn’t fly. Less of this, please, Ben…